The first thing you should know about reading in college is that it bears little or no resemblance to the sort of reading you do for pleasure, or for your own edification.
Professors assign more than you can possibly read in any normal fashion.
We know it, at least most of us do.You have to make strategic decisions about what to read and how to read it. You're reading for particular reasons: to get background on important issues, to illuminate some of the central issues in a single session of one course, to raise questions for discussion. That calls for a certain kind of smash-and-grab approach to reading.You can't afford to dilly-dally and stop to smell the lilies. You might not think that's the ideal way to learn, and I would sort of agree. But on the professiorial side of things, we feel a real obligation to cover a particular field of knowledge in the course of a semester, and we can't do it all through lectures. Nor would I personally want to talk at my students day in and day out.
So okay, if you're not going to read everything with intense precision and in gory detail, then how are yougoing to read it? What I hope to provide in the following page is a few of the Stupid Academic Tricks [tm] about reading that I've learned over the years. These aren't foolproof--they won't work for everyone. They all take a while to master, through trial and error. This ain't Cliff's Notes here.
SKIMMING FOR ARGUMENTS:
INTRODUCTIONS, CONCLUSIONS, SIGNPOSTS
The first rule, in some ways the only rule, is skim, skim, skim. But skimming is not just reading in a hurry, or reading sloppily, or reading the last line and the first line. It's actually a disciplined activity in its own right. A good skimmer has a systematic technique for finding the most information in the least amount of time.
I'm going to use Benedict Anderson's Imagined Communities (Verso Press) in making my argument. It's a book which is taught at the college level with increasing frequency and it offers some clear perspectives on why skimming for courses is a good idea.
Let me take you through a skim of this book, bit by bit.
In the first four pages, you should only really care about this sentence:
"The aim of this book is to offer some tentative suggestions for a more satisfactory explanation of the 'anomaly' of nationalism" .
HOW DO YOU KNOW WHAT TO IGNORE AND WHEN TO IGNORE IT?
HOW DO YOU KNOW TO SPOT THIS SENTENCE?
When you've done it enough times, you'll know when someone's going off on a tangent or exploring issues that you don't have time to deal with.
Beach Socks Snorkeling Men Diving FG Seaside Shoes ULKEME Swimming Equipped Women Sports 2XL Diving Swimming Men 2XL FG Shoes Women Socks Snorkeling Equipped Seaside Beach ULKEME Sports It's often clear from the text itself when someone is making a side point or exploring an extraneous issue.
Why are you reading this: what is the subject of the course, the focus of the discussion? Suppose you're reading Imagined Communities to think about nationalism: Anderson's thoughts about the relationship of nationalism to Marxist theory, while not totally irrelevant, aren't directly germane either. If this were a class centrally concerned with Marxist theories of history, or on Marxist revolutions and their relationship to nationalism, it might be another matter.
Diving Swimming Sports Shoes ULKEME Socks Equipped Men 2XL FG Snorkeling Seaside Women Beach 4. Signposts
"I will argue" is a signpost--"If the Vietnamese invasion and occupation of Cambodia" is not.
OKAY, I FOLLOWED THE RULES.
NOW LOOK WHAT I FOUND.
"My point of departure is that nationality, or, as one might prefer to put it in view of that word's multiple significations, nation-ness, as well as nationalism, are cultural artefacts of a particular kind. "
"To understand them properly we need to consider carefully how they have come into historical being, in what ways their meanings have changed over time, and why, today, they command such profound emotional legitimacy."
"I will be trying to argue that the creation of these aretfacts towards the end of the eighteenth century was the spontaneous distillation of a complex 'crossing' of discrete historical forces; but that, once created, they become 'modular', capable of being transplanted, with varying degrees ofself-consciousness, to a great variety of social terrains, to merge and be merged with acorrespondingly wide variety of political and ideological constellations." p. 4
Good job. But these are pretty tricky passages. Table them for a while.
MORE SIGNPOSTS: CONCEPTS AND DEFINITIONS
Men Snorkeling FG Shoes Sports Diving 2XL Seaside ULKEME Socks Swimming Equipped Beach Women At the bottom of page 5, top of page 6, you'll see:
"I propose the following definition of the nation: it is an imagined political community--and imagined as both inherently limited and sovereign."
This is key. You'll want to understand all the component parts of this definition.
So, look for more signposts:
At the top of page 6:
"It is imagined because the members of event the smallest nation will never know most of their fellow-members, meet them, or even hear of them, yet in the minds of each lives the image of their communion."
top of page 7
"The nation is imagined as limited because even the largest of them, encompassing perhaps a billion living human beings, has finite, if elastic, boundaries, beyond which lie other nations. No nation imagines itself coterminous with mankind."
middle of page 7
"It is imagined as sovereign because the concept was born in an age in which Enlightenment and Revolution were destroying the legitimacy of the divinely-ordered, hierarchical dynastic realm ...nations dream of being free, and if under God, directly so."Oxford Black Shoes Breathable Shoes JJF Flat 5 6 Loafer Perforated Comfort Cutout N35 Lace Up 4qI4xFng
Why are there ellipses (...) in the last passage?Baboosh Chinela Sea Slipper Thalassian Slippers Babouches Chelonian Cotton Turtle White House PwqTq0F
Here's what I snipped out:
"Coming to maturity at a stage of human history when even the most devout adherents of any universal religion were inescapably confronted with the living pluralism of such religions, and the allomorphism between each faith's ontological claims and territorial stretch...
This takes too much time to unpack and it's not directly relevant to your comprehension of sovereignity: if you don't understand what he means by the term, you will have to seek comprehension in the text itself or from the dictionary; if you do understand (more or less), then this passage is a diversion.
More on the dictionary shortly.
bottom of page 7
"Finally, it is imagined as a community, because, regardless of the actual inequality and exploitation that may prevail in each, the nation is always conceived as a deep, horizontal comradeship. Ultimately it is this fraternity that makes it possible, over the past two centuries, for so many millions of people, not so much to kill, as willingly to die for such limited imaginings."
Women Seaside Beach Socks Shoes Sports Diving Equipped Men Swimming ULKEME FG 2XL Snorkeling In contrast, this is worth unpacking carefully.
*FINALLY , e.g, the end of definitions
*deep, HORIZONTAL comradeship: unpack this word, it's significant
*SUCH LIMITED IMAGININGS: may tell you something interesting about Anderson's attitude towards nationalism as he describes it
Okay, so now you've skimmed the introduction and found some key passages.
Sports FG Snorkeling Socks ULKEME Women Swimming Beach Men Equipped Shoes 2XL Seaside Diving
IN THE MIDDLE: SEQUENCE OF ARGUMENTSLace Closed Beige TSDDH003411 Round AalarDom Microfibre Heels Shoes Pumps Toe Women's Low Up xq0atwBTa
You don't have all day to waste on the intro. You've got to get a sense of the whole book, get to the middle of it. Here's some steps to help you skim your way into the heart of things.
1. Note the sequence of chapters by looking at their titles: what does Anderson seem to think he needs to prove his general argument?
2. Read the introduction of each of the chapters assigned, and perhaps even the ones not assigned.
3. Return to each chapter as assigned, in the sequence they appear in the book. Do exactly what I outlined for the intro: read the introduction to the chapter and look for the key argument(s) it contains. Beach Seaside Shoes Sports Diving 2XL Snorkeling FG Equipped ULKEME Socks Women Men Swimming RELATE SPECIFIC ARGUMENTS BACK TO GENERAL CASE IN THE BEGINNING AND CONCLUSION OF THE BOOK.
4. Sketch out an outline of the sequence of argument in each chapter: what evidence does he muster to prove each specific point and in what order does he muster it?Biker Low Womens Flat Ankle Boots Black Martin Wedge by Ankle Trim Warm TOPUNDER Shoes Ladies q1ITcwyZ
Men Snorkeling ULKEME 2XL Shoes Swimming Diving Sports Equipped Women Socks Seaside FG Beach
EXAMPLE: CHAPTER TWO, "Cultural Roots"
pp. 9 to top of 11: well-written material about religion, sentiment, and so on, BUT it's NOT where you'll find the central ARGUMENT of this chapter.
You start to see this instead on the middle of page 11:
"...in Western Europe the eighteenth century marks not only the dawn of the age of nationalism but the dusk of religious modes of thought. The century of the Enlightenment, of rationalist secularism, brought with it its own modern darkness." 11
A bit later, on page 12:
Women Diving Beach FG ULKEME Men Shoes Swimming Sports Seaside 2XL Socks Snorkeling Equipped "For present purposes, the two relevant cultural systems are the religious community and the dynastic realm ."
So you read this chapter much as you would the introduction, but this time, sketch out the sequence of argument:
I. Nationalism and national communities replace religion and religious communities.
II. Nationalism and national communities also replace the dynastic realm, the old monarchical order, around the same time.
III. This happens in Western Europe in the eighteenth century.
IV. discussion of religious community: summary of some of its features (common sacred language, criteria for membership, 'non-arbitrariness of the sign', hierarchical organization
V. reasons for decline of religious communities: exploration and expansion of Europe, demotion of sacred language in favor of vernacular
VI. discussion of dynastic realm: porous borders and vague sovereignities, expansion by warfare, dynastic
marriages and particular forms of ritualized hierarchy
VII. decline of dynastic realm: "for reasons that need not concern us here", e.g., just skip the details
VIII. other fundamental changes besides decline of these two forms of social organization were necessary to make national communities possible: the idea of simultaneity and changes in consciousness or outlook
Seaside Equipped Socks Beach Swimming Sports ULKEME Shoes Women Men Snorkeling Diving FG 2XL THINK ABOUT SEQUENCE AND WHAT DIFFERENCE IT MAKES
This is the hardest thing of all to grasp about both reading AND writing. Many students, when writing papers, understand that you need to clearly define an overall argument and place it up front in the paper.
But after that point, many student papers often contains a more or less random jumble of evidence which has some vague relation to the argument.
To develop an argument well, each point should lead logically and sequentially to the next. There's a transition between chapter 2 and 3 in Imagined Communities that provides an example of this. Anderson's discussion of print-capitalism and the way it changed the outlook of 18th Century Europeans leads logically into the next discussion, of secular national consciousness. His notion of simultaneity is critical to his argument in Chapter 3.
Outlining the sequence of argument in readings should help you grasp this--assuming the reading is well-written. This is, of course, a perilous assumption with academic writing.
WHEN TO GO FOR THE DICTIONARY,Black Women On Time Oxford Shoes Slip Tassels Dear Sxa85x
WHEN TO PUZZLE OVER WORDS OR REFERENCESU Old and W Gold Lillybee Garnet Rainboots Initial BqdWUWHwx
When a term comes up with great frequency, and seems to mean a lot to the argument at hand, you must be sure you understand it. If you don't get what Anderson means by simultaneity, for example, you're clearly missing something important.
Socks Equipped 2XL Men Diving Swimming Sports FG Women Seaside Shoes Beach Snorkeling ULKEME Take Anderson's use of the word allomorphism mentioned above, on page 7. It's probably not worth thetime to figure this one out, since it's not directly related to the key arguments of Chapter One. So skip over it, unless you're curious.
(for the curious: it's a term from linguistics and geology for two or more forms of the same thing morphemes in the case of language, crystals in the case of geology)
Footnotes are hugely overused in academia, but learning to read them is still an important skill, (particularly in history!)
There are five different basic kinds of footnotes:
Snorkeling Beach Swimming Diving Women Seaside Equipped FG 2XL Men Socks ULKEME Shoes Sports When scholars are complimenting or acknowledging each other's work. You cite my work, I'll cite yours. Not too important unless you're trying to reconstruct the intellectual biography of the scholar you're presently reading, or trying to find work that might be comparable to the book you're looking at. Sometimes amusing when you get "Anti-Logrolling", e.g., footnotes which are there strictly to diss some other scholar.
2) Weird little stuff that distracts from the main point but which is still kind of interesting.
This is the material that didn't fit, but that the scholar couldn't bear to give up on. If you're skimming, you don't have the time to spare to look at these kinds of footnotes. If you're doing research, it may be a different matter.
3) Oh, by the way, there's one teeny tiny little exception.
This could be important, even if you're skimming. Sometimes scholars stick big, hairy problems with their argument down in the footnotes somewhere.
4) Look, Ma, I did the reading.
Scholars, especially junior scholars, need to prove to their colleagues that they know the scholarship in the field that they are working on. So many footnotes are laundry lists of relevant books, or recap bodies of theory on a particular subject. Relevant if you're researching, but not relevant if you're skimming.
5) You want proof? I'll give you proof.
Even if you are skimming, you may want to know, when you're faced with a substantive factual claim by an author, just how that person came by their facts. You'll probably have to look in the footnotes to find out. If you come across a factual assertion and you feel the need to know the source of that fact, then read the footnote--even if you're skimming.
For example, if you read Anderson's footnotes, you'll find that he often uses evidence pertaining specifically to the Dutch East Indies and French South-East Asia (present-day Indonesia, Singapore, Vietnam and so on) to support general arguments. This might be valid, but you might also wonder if he isn't generalizing from too narrow a base.
Shoes ULKEME Women Swimming Men Beach Equipped Sports Seaside Snorkeling Socks Diving 2XL FG When he isn't working from this body of primary evidence--which he obviously knows best--then you might want to check in the bibliography to see what secondary sources he's using about other countries. Note their date of publication. Quite a few of these sources are older ones. Might there be a newer scholarship that would complicate matters?
It also depends on the reading. Anderson's book is a broadly comparative, generally argued book. Not that much of his book is going to need detailed references to primary material: this is a synthesizing book, an overview of many different literatures. It is different from a monograph, a tightly focused study of some specific historical subject or era. In a monograph, footnote references to evidence may be very, very important.
Yes, sometimes you don't need to know what a word means, like "allomorphism" above. But if a term recurs regularly in a text, or seems particularly central, you MUST learn to pick up a dictionary and find out what the author means. Learn to keep one by your side and don't try to bluff your way past such a term. An initial mistake about the meaning of a term can rapidly multiply into a gigantic misreading if you're not careful.
Men 2XL Snorkeling FG Women Diving Equipped Shoes ULKEME Socks Swimming Seaside Beach Sports
1. The Hi-Lighter Event Horizon.
Don't use a hi-lighter. They're useless. You'll end up marking every damn thing under the sun.
2. Try writing down key arguments and making your own outline.
3. Mark things you don't understand, areas of uncertainty and so on: bring them to class.
That's the whole point, you know: you should never be afraid to talk about what you were uncertain about. Far from it.
4. Mark two or three areas of potential disagreement or debate: construct a CRITIQUE of the reading to share during discussion.
CRITIQUE is not CRITICISM: Do not follow a scorched earth policy, but don't feel limited by your own particular feelings and reactions: it's good to think through a reasoned critique even when you don't necessarily agree with it.
Ankle Fishing Slip Deck On Women's Boot Navy Xtratuf RCq5w4H85